Ghost Clients and Unspoken Stories

There are people in your client’s story who never make it onto the record. A dead parent. An abusive coach. A child they lost touch with. A former version of themselves they’re ashamed of. These invisible figures—their absences, their echoes—shape everything. And the jury feels them, even if they’re never named.

In BTC, we call this the ghost layer of the story. It’s the part of the social atom that isn't listed on the chart but radiates power across the timeline of the case. If you ignore these ghost clients—these silent characters—you risk building a story that makes logical sense but emotional nonsense.

 

The Ghost Layer Is Real

In Moreno’s language, the social atom is the set of significant relationships a person carries—past and present, real or imagined. But in the courtroom, we often strip the story down to what's admissible. What’s allowed. What’s safe.

But jurors pick up on what’s missing. A client talks about their choices but never mentions anyone guiding them. They show emotion but offer no names. A silence stretches too long. Something doesn’t match.

And so the juror—like any human—fills in the blanks. Sometimes inaccurately. Sometimes dangerously.

 

Role Practice Illuminates the Unseen

In our BTC witness prep circles, we often use an exercise called “Invisible Atoms.” We ask:

  • Who is in the room when you tell this story?

  • Who are you protecting by staying vague?

  • Who are you still arguing with—inside your head?

Then we rehearse telling the story to them. Not the jury. Not the lawyer. To the ghost in the story. It changes everything.

When the emotional truth of the story is honored—not just the admissible one—clients breathe easier. They speak with less force and more depth. And jurors listen differently.

 

Truth Is Larger Than the Record

Your job isn’t to flood the court with everything. Your job is to find the resonant role relationships that hold meaning, and bring them to life without sacrificing clarity. BTC gives you the tools to do that—without collapsing into oversharing or vagueness.

When you know which ghosts are in the room, your presence shifts. You carry your client’s story with a steadier hand.

 

Subscribe to my Substack for weekly breakdowns, exercises, and behind-the-scenes strategies from BTC. https://buildingthecase.substack.com/

Leigh Johnson

Leigh E. Johnson—A Master of Storytelling in the Legal Arena

In the high-stakes world of trial lawyering, where facts clash and narratives collide, Leigh E. Johnson stands out as a guide for crafting stories that win hearts, minds, and cases. As a trial lawyer and founder of Trial Whisperer and Law Focus Groups, Leigh has dedicated her career to transforming complex legal battles into compelling human stories that resonate deeply with juries and clients alike.

Leigh’s innovative approach is rooted in action methods, which she uses to uncover the emotional core of every case. By combining rigorous analysis with creativity and empathy, she helps legal teams transform raw evidence into narratives that transcend legal jargon, capturing universal truths and driving courtroom success.

Her journey is as unique as the strategies she employs. From managing communications in military combat units to controlling airspace as an air traffic controller and even working in biotechnology, Leigh’s diverse experiences have shaped her unmatched ability to think creatively under pressure and frame the hidden elements of any story. A graduate and faculty member of Gerry Spence’s Trial Lawyers College, she has trained countless lawyers in the art of storytelling, psychology, and narrative structure.

In this book, Leigh shares the techniques and insights she has honed over decades—tools that empower professionals to create powerful, impactful stories, whether in the courtroom or beyond. Through her lens, storytelling becomes more than a skill; it becomes the bridge between facts and understanding, between strategy and victory.

Let Leigh be your guide as you explore the art and science of the story spine, a transformative framework that has shaped the outcomes of trials, leadership strategies, and lives.

Next
Next

When the Jury Isn’t Listening to What You Think They Are